Are natural sweeteners really better for you?
Honey’s wellness benefits are plausible, study puts them to the test
As the new year sets in some are trying a sugar-free January.
We’re encouraged to limit sugar and sweeteners in our diet. The American Heart Association advises no more than 6 teaspoons a day for women, 9 for men, and for added sugar to provide no more than 5-10 percent of daily calories. Excess added sugar is linked with obesity, and many chronic diseases such as type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome and heart disease.
And since we like sweet food – to prefer sweet foods is to be human – are there healthier ways to sweeten food? Are honey, maple syrup, agave and date syrup any better?
Sugar is sugar?
Honey is made by honeybees from the nectar of flowers, and contains, besides sugars, a whole array of organic acids, enzymes, proteins, amino acids, minerals, vitamins, and bioactive substances. It has been shown that honey has beneficial effects on sugar control, weight maintenance, inflammation, lipid profile, and as a common cold remedy.
A new systematic review published in Nutrition Reviews including 18 controlled clinical trials set to examine honey’s health effects.
It found that a median dose of 40 grams (about 2 tablespoons) daily over 8 weeks reduced blood fasting sugar, cholesterol, and triglycerides levels. Raw honey was more effective than honey that was heat treated – most of the benefits demonstrated are from studies that use raw honey.
This review is in line with animal studies: several studies in rats show that regular honey intake results in better sugar control and lipid profiles.
Honey’s wellness benefits are plausible: Honey is 80 percent sugar, mostly fructose and glucose, but there are also “rare sugars” in honey, those include monosaccharides and their derivatives (such as isomaltulose), which have effects on fats and on gut microbes. Honey contains phenolic compounds and flavonoids and other important antioxidants. Raw honey contains probiotic beneficial bacteria that are known to regulate the immune system and improve lipid profiles.
The flower source of the honey also matters – clover honey, and robinia honey were especially beneficial for fasting blood sugar control and cholesterol reduction.
Swapping sugar with honey
Honey is still in the “added sugar” category, and as such, should be enjoyed in moderation. Replacing sugar with honey can help with moderation, as you’ll be skipping most processed foods – which are made with refined sugar and high fructose corn syrup. Honey’s price point and nuisance value can help limit your consumption.
A “no refined added sugar” principal that allows for natural sweeteners can make sense if it helps you keep a lid on your sweet tooth.
The added nutrients in honey can also add a bit of wellness.
The authors of the study also suggest that honey should not be lumped with the other refined added sugars which provide nothing but energy (empty calories): “as honey, when taken in moderation, may offer a variety of benefits for glycemic control and lipid levels.”
The key is moderation. I do believe that sweets and dessert have a place in a healthy diet. But a cake doesn't become “health food” because it’s sweetened by honey – cake is still cake.
Dr. Ayala